Granite and quartz are two of the most popular choices for kitchen and bathroom countertops. But which one is more affordable? Here’s a detailed comparison of granite vs quartz countertops to help you decide which material fits your budget.
Introduction
When choosing new countertops, cost is often a major factor. Granite and quartz are both natural stone materials that provide an upscale, stylish look. But they vary significantly in price.
Quartz counters are engineered from ground quartz crystals combined with resins and pigments. Granite slabs are cut directly from natural stone. The manufacturing process makes quartz more consistent in pattern and color, while granite offers a unique, natural look.
Below we examine the cost differences between quartz and granite, including material and installation pricing. We’ll also look at factors like maintenance, durability, and resale value that impact long-term costs. This will help you determine whether granite or quartz offers the better value for your kitchen or bath remodel.
Material Costs
Quartz countertops are generally less expensive than granite.
On average, quartz costs $40-100 per square foot installed. Mid to upper-tier quartz runs $70-120 per square foot installed.
Granite slabs run $60-185 per square foot installed. Mid to high-end granite ranges $80-185 per square foot installed.
So while prices vary based on stone color and quality, quartz is usually 25-50% cheaper than granite. Quartz offers a lower material cost because it’s engineered, not hand-cut like natural granite.
Factors Influencing Price
Several factors impact the price of both quartz and granite counters:
- Stone color & style – Basic white or beige quartz and granite cost less than premium options like exotic granite or quartz with vibrant colors or patterns.
- Thickness – 3 cm slabs run lower than 2 cm. Granite is often available in 3 cm. Most quartz is only manufactured in 2 cm.
- Edge treatments – Decorative edges like ogee, bevel, or eased cost extra. A basic straight edge is the most affordable.
- Add-ons – Backsplashes, specialty cutting for sinks or stovetops, and multiple slab seams add to installed costs.
- Regional pricing – Costs are typically lower outside of major metro areas and on the coasts.
- Brand – Price varies slightly between leading national quartz brands like Caesarstone, Cambria, and Silestone.
Installation Cost Comparison
In addition to material costs, installation is a significant portion of your total countertop investment.
On average, granite installation runs $35-50 per square foot and quartz installation costs $20-35 per square foot. Quartz requires less labor time and expertise to install due to its uniform surface. Complex granite cutting and polishing is more labor intensive.
Pros & Cons Impacting Costs
Beyond upfront pricing, pros and cons of each material affect long term value:
Granite
Pros:
- Huge variety of natural patterns & colors. Can find very high end and more budget options.
- Retains excellent resale value, 75-100% ROI.
Cons:
- Requires yearly sealing = added maintenance costs.
- Can stain, crack and chip if not properly sealed.
Quartz
Pros:
- Extremely durable. Resistant to scratches, stains and damage.
- Low maintenance. No sealing required.
Cons:
- Limited number of colors/patterns. Trends can fade.
- Lower resale value around 50% ROI.
So while granite can chip and stain if not sealed properly, quartz is virtually maintenance free. And quartz offers fewer unique options since it’s engineered.
Average Total Installation Costs
Given all the factors above, here are typical total installed costs for granite and quartz countertops:
- Basic Quartz: $2,500 – $3,500
- High-end Quartz: $3,500 – $5,500
- Basic Granite: $4,000 – $6,000
- High-end Granite: $6,000 – $9,000
As you can see, quartz consistently comes in 25-50% lower than granite for both basic and high-end materials.
FAQs
Is quartz cheaper than granite?
Yes, quartz is generally 25-50% cheaper than granite. Quartz material costs $40-100 per square foot installed compared to $60-185 per square foot for granite.
Is granite worth the extra cost over quartz?
It depends. Granite offers unique natural patterns. But quartz is extremely durable and maintenance free. If your budget accommodates granite, it can be a good investment in terms of resale value. Overall quartz offers more affordability.
Does quartz add or detract home value compared to granite?
Granite generally provides a higher return on investment around 75-100% ROI. Quartz offers approximately 50% ROI. So granite may recoup more of its upfront cost. But quartz still boosts home value for a lower initial investment.
How much does basic quartz countertop cost?
A basic quartz countertop costs $2,500 – $3,500 installed. This assumes mid-grade quartz at $70 per square foot and average installation cost of $25 per square foot.
How much does high-end granite countertop cost?
For a premium granite slab at $185 per square foot and typical installation of $50 per square foot, expect to pay $6,000 – $9,000 for a high-end granite countertop.
The Bottom Line
While granite can provide a great return on investment, quartz delivers an upscale look at a more affordable price point. The dramatic cost differences make quartz the clear choice if you’re on a tight budget.
But granite can make sense if you appreciate rare, natural patterns and can accommodate the higher price. Be sure to factor in maintenance and durability when making your decision between granite vs quartz countertops.