Quartz countertops have become incredibly popular in recent years, and for good reason. They are affordable, durable, stylish, and easy to maintain. However, quartz is not necessarily the best option for every home. There are several countertop materials that can outperform quartz in certain ways.
Granite Countertops
Granite is a natural stone that has been used for countertops for generations. Like quartz, granite is very durable and resistant to scratches, heat, and stains. However, granite offers some distinct advantages over quartz:
More Unique Appearance
Granite slabs come directly from the earth, so no two pieces are alike. The natural patterning and veining of granite make each slab completely unique. Quartz counters may look more uniform, while granite offers one-of-a-kind visual appeal.
Can Be Repolished
Over time, granite can lose its shine and begin to show signs of wear. Unlike quartz, granite can be repolished and restored to look like new again. Quartz cannot be repolished if the surface becomes damaged.
Higher Resale Value
In general, granite countertops will increase property value more than quartz. The unique, high-end look of natural granite is favored by many home buyers.
However, granite does have some downsides to consider:
- More expensive upfront cost
- Requires periodic sealing to prevent stains
- More prone to chipping and cracking if poorly installed
Marble Countertops
For an even more luxurious natural stone look, marble countertops are a splendid choice. Here’s how marble compares to quartz:
Gorgeous Visual Depth
The swirls and veins in marble run much deeper than in quartz or granite. Marble counters have an unmatchable depth and richness that makes them stand out.
Softer Material
Marble is composed of a softer limestone, making it easier to carve intricately and polish to a smooth sheen. The softness does make it more prone to etching and scratching from acidic foods and abrasives though.
Requires More Maintenance
Marble needs to be resealed regularly, sometimes as often as once a month. It also needs gentle cleaning with non-acidic products. Quartz is basically maintenance-free.
Rarer and Pricier
True marble is relatively rare and must be extracted from quarries in select locations worldwide. This makes it more exclusive and expensive than engineered quartz.
Concrete Countertops
Concrete has become a highly sought-after countertop material for modern, industrial-chic kitchens. Here’s how it compares to quartz:
Extremely Durable
Concrete contains stone aggregates that make it even more durable than quartz. It can withstand heavy impacts without damage. Heat and scratches are no match for concrete.
Can Be Custom Colored
Concrete counters can be pigmented and stained to achieve virtually any color imaginable. Unique embedded accents like glass fragments or seashells can also be added.
Develops a Patina Over Time
Unlike quartz which retains its uniform appearance, concrete develops a natural patina as it ages. This lends more character and vintage appeal.
Requires Monthly Sealing
To prevent staining and damage from moisture, concrete needs to be treated with a sealant about once a month. Quartz requires no sealing at all.
Highly Customizable
Concrete offers limitless customization possibilities. It can be precast in any shape – curved, angled, textured, or exceedingly smooth. Quartz only comes in slab form.
Soapstone Countertops
For a uniquely soft, earthy style, soapstone counters are the way to go. So how does soapstone stack up against quartz?
Nonporous & Stain-Resistant
Soapstone won’t absorb stains or harbor bacteria within pores like some natural stones. Spills can simply be wiped away. It’s about on par with quartz for stain resistance.
Develops a Lustrous Patina
The more soapstone is used and oiled, the darker and richer its color becomes over time. This gives it an aged, Old World look that quartz lacks.
Excellent Heat Tolerance
Soapstone has incredible heat resistance. Hot pans and baking sheets can be placed directly on it without worry of damage. It holds heat well too.
Prone to Scratching
Being a relatively soft stone, soapstone can be scratched more easily than quartz. Heavy abrasion is required to damage quartz.
Needs Frequent Re-oiling
To maintain its patina and moisture resistance, soapstone requires re-oiling every few weeks. Quartz never needs resealing or oiling.
Solid Surface Countertops
Brands like Corian pioneered solid surface counters as an alternative to natural stone. Let’s examine how they compare with quartz:
Seamless Appearance
Solid surface slabs can be joined seamlessly to create flowing countertops free of disruptive seams. Quartz countertops will always have visible seams.
Easy to Repair
Minor damage like scratches, scorches, and stains can be sanded away from solid surface material. Quartz cannot be repaired – damaged sections must be replaced.
Prone to Heat Damage
Exposing solid surface counters to very hot pans can cause bubbling, discoloration, and permanent marks. Quartz can withstand much more heat.
Fewer Color Choices
There are limited color options for solid surface material. Quartz comes in a vast array of natural-looking colors and patterns.
Lower Cost
Solid surface countertops are typically cheaper than natural quartz. The engineered material costs less to produce.
FAQs About Countertop Materials
What is the most durable kitchen countertop material?
Quartz and granite tend to be the most durable options. Both stand up well to heavy use, scratches, heat, and stains. Granite may have a slight edge due to being naturally hard and dense.
Which countertop adds the most value to a home?
Natural stone countertops like granite and especially marble add the most value for resale. Their rare natural beauty and durability are highly desirable. Quartz and solid surface materials add less value.
Is quartz toxic or unhealthy?
Quartz surfaces contain high percentages of ground natural stone, so they are not harmful or toxic. Some brands use small amounts of polymer resins to bind the stone particles, but these meet health standards.
How often do countertops need to be sealed?
Quartz never needs sealing. For other common countertop materials: Granite – Once a year, Marble – Once a month, Concrete – Once a month, Soapstone – Every few weeks.
What’s the biggest drawback of quartz counters?
The major downside of quartz is that it lacks the natural variation and one-of-a-kind uniqueness of real stone. The man-made material has a more uniform, manufactured look.
Conclusion
While quartz counters are currently popular, they aren’t necessarily the best choice for every kitchen. Countertop materials like granite, marble, and concrete can provide a more distinctive visual appeal. Options like soapstone and solid surface offer unique traits like heat tolerance or repairability. It pays to look beyond quartz to find the ideal countertop for your space and lifestyle. Focus on your priorities like budget, maintenance needs, and style preferences. With an abundance of options available, you can certainly discover a material even better than quartz.