Quartz and granite are two of the most popular countertop materials used in kitchens and bathrooms today. But which one is better? Here is an in-depth comparison of quartz vs granite countertops to help you decide which is the right choice for your home.
Introduction
When it comes time to choose new countertops, quartz and granite are leading choices for many homeowners. Both offer elegance, durability, and style. However, there are some key differences between these two natural stone materials that are important to consider before making a decision. Evaluating the pros and cons of quartz vs granite countertops can help determine which is the superior material for your home and lifestyle.
Quartz Countertops Overview
Quartz countertops, often referred to as engineered stone, are made from ground natural quartz crystals combined with polymer resins and pigments. The mixture is molded into slabs and polished into the finished product. Here are some of the pros of quartz:
- Extremely durable and resistant to scratches, stains, heat, and cracks
- Available in a wide range of colors and patterns
- Non-porous so does not need to be sealed
- Easy maintenance with soap and water
- Resists bacteria growth
- Seamless appearance
- Warm to the touch
Some cons to consider:
- Less natural look than real stone
- Can be damaged by sharp impacts
- Repairs and replacements may be noticeable
- Higher cost than granite
Brands like Silestone, Caesarstone, Cambria, and Viatera are popular quartz countertop manufacturers.
Granite Countertops Overview
Granite is a completely natural stone that is mined from quarries. It is an igneous rock formed from cooled magma. Granite tends to have a more elegant, unique appearance with natural variations. Here are some pros:
- Each slab has a completely unique natural pattern
- Withstands heat well
- Extremely durable and scratch-resistant
- Easy to clean and maintain
- Timeless, classic material that doesn’t go out of style
- Potentially higher resale value
Some cons of granite:
- More expensive than quartz
- Needs to be sealed periodically
- Can stain from spills if not sealed properly
- More likely to chip or crack if subjected to impact
- Limited color options compared to quartz
Brazil, India, and Italy are places known for their granite.
Quartz vs Granite Comparison
Now let’s dive into a detailed comparison of some of the most important factors when choosing between quartz and granite.
Appearance
Granite has an elegant, timeless look that is completely unique based on its natural variations. It can have dramatic veining, spots, and movements of color. Quartz has a more uniform appearance, although modern manufacturing techniques allow quartz to mimic granite and marble. Ultimately granite offers more variety in terms of patterns and aesthetic options.
Durability
Both materials are very durable, but quartz is slightly tougher than granite. Granite can chip if subjected to impact. Quartz is virtually non-porous and resists scratches and heat better than granite. However, quartz can potentially be damaged by heavy impacts that would not harm granite.
Maintenance
Quartz requires very little maintenance besides cleaning with soap and water. It never needs to be sealed. Granite is also easy to clean, but it must be sealed once a year to prevent staining and deterioration over time. So quartz wins when it comes to avoiding ongoing maintenance.
Cost
Quartz is generally more expensive than granite. The resin and manufacturing process makes it a premium priced material. However, granite pricing can vary quite a bit based on the source and rarity of the stone. Unique granite types can equal or exceed the cost of quartz. Overall granite tends to have a lower starting price point than quartz.
Colors and Patterns
Thanks to technology, quartz patterns and colors are practically limitless. Granite colors are dependent on natural mineral variations and are generally more limited in scope. One advantage of granite is that each slab is completely unique. No two are exactly the same.
Resale Value
Natural granite may have a slight edge in terms of resale value and being perceived as a premium material. However, both materials should retain their value well if properly installed and maintained.
Eco-Friendliness
Granite is a 100% natural material, making it inherently eco-friendly. Quartz uses more energy and man-made materials in its manufacturing process. However, quartz countertops can last a very long time, minimizing replacement and landfill waste. Both materials can be seen as green options.
Pros and Cons Summary
Quartz Pros:
- Most durable and scratch-resistant surface
- Requires little maintenance
- Resists stains and heat
- Wide range of colors and patterns
Quartz Cons:
- Less natural look than granite
- Needs replacement/repair if damaged
- More expensive
Granite Pros:
- Timeless, classic material
- Completely natural and unique
- Withstands heat well
- Durable and scratch-resistant
Granite Cons:
- Needs annual sealing
- Can chip or stain more easily
- Limited color options
- More expensive than quartz
Which is Better: Quartz or Granite?
When choosing between quartz vs granite countertops, there are good arguments to be made for either material. Granite is beloved for its elegance and timeless appeal. But quartz offers superior durability and almost no maintenance requirements.
Ultimately, quartz seems to have a slight edge for most homeowners based on its resistance to scratches, stains, and cracks with little upkeep needed. The wide variety of quartz patterns and colors to suit any style is also a major advantage. Home chefs may also prefer quartz for its durability against heat and stains.
However, the natural beauty of granite cannot be replicated. For those desiring a material with unrivaled elegance that makes a statement, granite may be worth the higher maintenance needs. It also can have greater perceived value for home resale.
Carefully examine your budget, aesthetic preferences, and lifestyle needs when deciding between these two premier countertop materials. Consult with an expert kitchen designer to further assess which is better suited for your space. In the end, you cannot go wrong with either quartz or granite countertops in your home.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is quartz or granite better for kitchen countertops?
For most kitchens, quartz makes the better choice due to its superior durability against scratches, stains, impacts, and heat. The lack of required sealing and minimal maintenance of quartz also gives it an advantage for countertops that experience heavy use.
Which material is more expensive, quartz or granite?
Generally quartz countertops will be more expensive than granite. However, unique granite types from rare sources can sometimes cost more than quartz.
Is quartz more durable than granite?
Yes, quartz is slightly more durable overall. Granite will resist chips and cracks if installed and maintained properly though. But quartz is virtually non-porous and highly resilient.
Which countertop adds more value to a home?
Granite may potentially add slightly more value to a home upon resale due to its prestige and classic appeal. But well-maintained quartz countertops will certainly boost resale value as well.
How often does granite need to be sealed?
It is recommended to have granite sealed by a professional approximately once per year to maintain its water resistance and prevent staining or etching of the surface over time.
Conclusion
When choosing a countertop, quartz and granite surfaces each have their advantages. Granite brings timeless beauty and elegance with its natural variations. Quartz offers superior durability and less maintenance. For most homeowners, quartz provides the best combination of visual appeal, functionality, and convenience. Consult with kitchen design specialists and examine your own needs carefully when deciding between quartz vs granite countertops. Either material can provide long-lasting countertops that will enhance your home’s beauty.