When it comes to choosing between quartz and granite countertops, one of the biggest considerations for many homeowners is cost. Both materials are natural stones that can provide an elegant look, but which one costs more? Here is a detailed comparison of quartz vs granite countertops on price to help you make the best decision for your kitchen or bathroom remodeling project.
Factors That Determine Quartz and Granite Pricing
The cost of both quartz and granite varies quite a bit based on several factors:
Material Quality
- Granite comes in many grades from commercial quality to the highest-end slabs sourced from specific quarries. More unique, rare granite comes at a premium price.
- Quartz is an engineered stone made from roughly 90% ground quartz and polymers. Higher-end brands use higher purity quartz and more polymers for increased durability and aesthetics. Budget quartz often uses lower grade quartz.
Color and Pattern
- More consistent subtle quartz patterns are widely available, so complex granites with unique coloring and veining are more valuable.
- Some trendy quartz color styles come at a higher cost due to popularity.
Rarity
- Exotic granites from specific remote quarries command top dollar. Many budget granites are imported from abundant sources.
- Some quartz companies restrict distribution for certain styles driving up prices on “rare” options.
Thickness
- Granite slabs typically range from 2 to 4 cm thick. 3 cm is standard, with thicker slabs costing more.
- Most quartz is fabricated at 2 cm with 3 cm options at an upcharge. Thicker quartz is more resistant to damage.
Fabrication & Installation
- Intricate granite fabrication requiring multiple seams or curved edges adds costs. Simple layouts and square edges are most budget-friendly.
- Quartz fabrication techniques are relatively uniform, leading to smaller price differences. Installation prices are similar for both.
Average Material Costs: Quartz vs Granite
Taking all these factors into account, here are typical material price ranges:
- Quartz countertops range from $40–$120 per square foot installed. Low-end quartz starts at $40. Higher-end designer brands can be over $100 per square foot.
- Granite countertops range from $35–$185 per square foot installed. Commercial granites can be as low as $35, while exotic granites with unique features can exceed $185.
On average, for a typical mid-grade product in standard thickness, quartz counters will cost $5–10 more per square foot than granite. However, granite has greater high-end and lower-end pricing options.
Is Quartz or Granite More Expensive Overall?
In most cases, for an average homeowner choosing a mid-tier color and style, quartz countertops will be slightly more expensive than granite. Initial material cost for an average kitchen will run about $100-500 higher for quartz vs granite.
However, that does not mean granite is always the budget option. There are some key considerations for long term value:
- Quartz requires very little maintenance unlike granite which needs periodic sealing. Over 5-10 years, maintenance costs add up.
- Quartz is less prone to damage like cracks, chips or scratches that can lead to costly granite repairs or replacement. It provides a better return on investment.
- More premium granite grades with rare features can far exceed the cost of high-end quartz. Exotic granite is in a tier of its own for luxury projects.
The bottom line? For most homeowners, quartz provides good value, beauty, and convenience to justify the slightly higher initial price tag in most cases. However, budget buyers and those wanting true stone luxury may still prefer granite. Carefully compare types available in your area and price range. An experienced countertop supplier can explain all options during a free consultation.
Factors That Impact Overall Installation Costs
For both quartz and granite countertops, the total installed price per square foot does not tell the whole story. You also have to look at the overall installation cost which factors in total size and layout.
Some key points that raise overall quartz and granite installation costs:
- The total square footage needed. Larger kitchens cost more overall.
- Multiple discontinuous sections like island counters or separate bars. Seams, corners, and cutouts add fabrication time and waste.
- Special edge profiles beyond standard eased or square edges. Decorative edges cost more.
- Integrated sinks require precision quartz or granite cutting. Undermount sinks add the most cost.
- Special structural needs like reinforced overhangs for waterfall edges or extra support for heavy ranges.
Get a itemized installation quote accounting for all your specific kitchen features to accurately compare granite vs quartz total costs. Be sure to get estimates from 3-5 reputable companies for the best deal.
Which Provides More Value Over Time?
While the upfront cost is important, also consider which material will look better and function reliably longer to get your money’s worth:
Quartz countertops tend to provide better long term value than granite for most homeowners for a few reasons:
- Simple maintenance. No sealing needed, just gentle cleaning. Saves time and hassle.
- Superior durability and stain/scratch resistance. Holds up better under heavy use.
- More consistent color patterns. Keeps a newer look longer than natural granite.
- Greater ROI. Adds value without requiring frequent repairs. Easy to resell home later.
However, granite can also be a smart investment if you choose one of the more resilient and timeless colors and patterns in a durable thickness. Taking care of it properly is key.
Neither material will be the right value for everyone. Look at average costs in your area for the grades you like, factor in quartz vs granite maintenance, and make the best long term investment for your unique kitchen.
FAQ About Granite vs Quartz Prices
Here are answers to some common questions about the cost differences between quartz and granite:
Is quartz more expensive than granite overall?
In most cases, yes, quartz is slightly pricier than granite for the average kitchen. But exotic high-end granites can far exceed even designer quartz.
Why is quartz more expensive than granite?
The price difference mainly comes down to quartz being an engineered and manufactured product. The technology and processes involved increase its cost over unprocessed natural granite.
Is quartz worth the extra cost over granite?
For many homeowners, yes, quartz provides good value benefits like minimal maintenance, superior durability, and reliable color consistency that justify spending a bit more.
Can granite be cheaper than quartz?
Yes, commercial quality granite in basic colors and patterns can be very affordable, often starting under $40/sq.ft. Be sure to examine granite grades closely.
Is granite better for those on a budget?
It can be, but don’t assume granite is always the cheapest option. Visit showrooms to compare pricing of different styles side-by-side. Some quartz grades rival low-cost granite pricing.
Should I expect to negotiate prices down for either material?
Pricing is usually firm on quartz, but granite retailers have more room to negotiate. Look for warehouse sales or remnants to get granite bargains.
The Bottom Line
While material and installation costs are central factors, also carefully consider whether quartz or granite offers the overall look, performance, and value you desire most. An experienced kitchen designer can provide objective guidance. Discuss your budget and goals to determine if those extra dollars for quartz or savings on granite make sense for your project. With either of these high-quality natural stone surfaces, you can gain a beautiful, functional kitchen to enjoy for decades.