Porcelain and quartz countertops are two of the most popular options for kitchen and bathroom remodeling projects today. But which one costs more? Here is a detailed comparison of porcelain vs. quartz countertop pricing.
Introduction
When selecting new countertops, cost is often a primary factor in the decision-making process. Porcelain and quartz are both durable, low-maintenance, and attractive options that can significantly upgrade your space. However, they come at different price points.
Quartz countertops are made from ground quartz crystals combined with resins and pigments. The result is a natural stone look with consistent color and pattern. Quartz is praised for its resistance to stains, heat, and scratches.
Porcelain countertops provide the look and feel of natural stone at a lower cost. Porcelain is an extremely durable ceramic material that can be shaped to resemble materials like marble, granite, and other stones. It offers exceptional resistance to staining, abrasion, and high temperatures.
Below is a detailed overview of typical installed costs, material prices, and the factors that influence the total expense of porcelain and quartz countertops.
Typical Installed Costs
The installed cost provides the complete price of the materials, fabrication, and professional installation of your new countertops. On average:
- The installed cost of quartz countertops ranges from $80 – $100 per square foot.
- The installed cost of porcelain countertops averages between $40 – $80 per square foot.
Quartz is almost always more expensive than porcelain when professionally installed. The material and fabrication costs of quartz are higher. However, the wide range for porcelain pricing shows the potential for overlap. The lowest grade porcelain could potentially cost less than mid-range quartz.
Material Cost Comparison
Looking specifically at material prices without installation gives further insight into the cost difference:
- Quartz slabs range from $50 – $120 per square foot with most between $65 – $85 per square foot.
- Porcelain slabs are commonly $25 – $50 per square foot. Some premium porcelain can reach up to $100 per square foot.
Again, quartz consistently commands a higher base price, with porcelain offering potential savings. However, premium porcelain that mimics high-end natural stone may bring it to a similar price point as mid-range quartz.
What Impacts the Costs?
Several factors contribute to the costs of porcelain and quartz countertops, causing pricing ranges and potential overlap:
Porcelain Cost Factors
- Thickness: Thicker porcelain slabs are more durable and retain heat better but cost more. Common thicknesses are 3/8″, 1/2″, and 5/8″.
- Colors and patterns: Simple colors and patterns are most economical. Imitations of rare marble and stone cost more.
- Finish: Matte and natural finishes are often standard. Polished, satin, or textured finishes add cost.
- Edge profiles: Fancy edge options like ogee, bevel, and dupont add labor and price.
- Brand: Leading brands like Dekton, Neolith, and Luce di Luna cost more than generic porcelain.
Quartz Cost Factors
- Color and pattern: Unusual colors and bold veining patterns increase the price. Whites and blacks are most affordable.
- Thickness: 3/4″ is standard. Thicker 1-1/4″ slabs add cost but are more resilient.
- Brand: Silestone, Caesarstone, and Cambria are premium brands that cost more than low-end quartz.
- Edge details: Upgraded edges like bevels, ogees, and bullnoses require special fabrication.
- Percentage of quartz: Some high-end quartz contains over 90% natural quartz, increasing cost.
Pros and Cons of Each Material
Beyond just costs, consider the pros and cons of quartz vs. porcelain:
Quartz Pros
- Consistent pattern and color
- Extremely durable and scratch-resistant surface
- Easy maintenance
- Resists heat and stains
Quartz Cons
- Higher cost
- Can chip if subject to impact
- Limited number of colors and styles
Porcelain Pros
- Extremely durable for long lifespan
- High heat resistance
- Mimics natural stone looks
- Large range of colors, finishes, and patterns
Porcelain Cons
- Prone to cracks if the substrate is not properly prepared
- Can chip from impact
- Grout lines more visible than quartz
Bottom Line
In most cases, quartz countertops will be more expensive than porcelain. However, premium porcelain that replicates rare natural stone may overlap with mid-range quartz pricing.
Quartz offers hassle-free maintenance, consistent patterning, and scratch resistance. Porcelain provides an attractive, durable surface that mimics stone at a lower cost. Carefully consider your budget, design goals, and how you use your kitchen or bath when deciding between quartz vs. porcelain countertops. Consult countertop installation professionals to get accurate quotes for your specific project.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is porcelain cheaper than granite?
Yes, porcelain is generally cheaper than natural granite. Porcelain starts around $25 per square foot while granite slab prices often begin around $50 per square foot.
Is porcelain cheaper than Corian countertops?
Porcelain is usually less expensive than Corian, an acrylic-based solid surface countertop material. Corian costs $55-$100 installed per square foot, more than many porcelain options.
Can porcelain crack or chip easily?
Porcelain is highly resistant to chips and cracks with proper installation. However, uneven cabinet bases or excessive impact force can cause cracks. High-quality porcelain is quite durable under normal conditions.
Does porcelain stain easily?
Quality porcelain resists stains exceptionally well. Like other ceramics, the dense, non-porous material prevents most liquids from penetrating the surface. It can withstand hot pots and pans, juices, oils and more.
Is porcelain good for kitchen countertops?
Yes, porcelain makes an excellent countertop material for kitchens. It provides the elegant look of stone with extreme durability and heat resistance. The smooth surface resists scratches, stains, and damage from daily use. Porcelain stands up well to heavy usage in busy kitchens.
Conclusion
While quartz nearly always commands a higher installed price, porcelain offers homeowners a chance to get the look of natural stone they desire at a more affordable cost. With smart selection of color, finish, thickness, and edge details, porcelain can be customized to fit most kitchen design schemes and budgets. Consult with countertop installation professionals to receive quotes on your specific project. Carefully evaluate the price, durability, and aesthetic factors that matter most to your goals.