Durability
When it comes to durability, quartz countertops are generally considered to be more resistant to scratches, stains, and heat than granite. Quartz is made from ground natural stone combined with resins and pigments, creating an engineered stone that is very hard and non-porous. Granite is a natural stone that can be porous and susceptible to stains if not properly sealed. However, granite is also very durable in terms of scratches, chips, and cracks. Overall, quartz requires less maintenance to retain its appearance over time.
Appearance
Granite has a natural beauty with distinctive veining, flecks, and patterns that make each slab unique. The appearance can range from solid colors to bold swirling designs. Quartz mimics the look of granite and other natural stones but lacks the same natural variation. However, quartz does offer a wide array of consistent patterns and colors created by the manufacturing process. Ultimately, granite offers a more distinctive, one-of-a-kind aesthetic compared to the uniformity of quartz.
Price
Quartz countertops tend to cost more than granite. The average installed price for quartz is $80-100 per square foot, while granite slabs run $40-100 per square foot. The pricing for both can vary based on factors like color, edge styles, and regional labor costs. Due to higher material costs, quartz is usually the more expensive option, but some premium granite can rival it in price.
Maintenance
Since quartz is non-porous, it does not need to be regularly sealed like natural stone. Granite should be sealed every 1-2 years to prevent staining. Quartz also resists scratches better than granite over time. However, quartz can be damaged by excessive heat, so trivets and hot pads should always be used. For daily cleaning, quartz and granite both benefit from mild soap and water. Overall, quartz requires less maintenance to keep it looking like new.
Fabrication
Quartz slabs are easier for fabricators to cut and install compared to the density and hardness of natural granite. Advanced tools and techniques are needed to work with granite. Seams may be more visible with quartz countertops compared to granite. The resins in quartz can cause the material to melt rather than cut cleanly. Granite offers a more seamless appearance when installed properly.
Sustainability
If eco-friendliness is a priority, granite has an advantage as a 100% natural material sourced locally in many regions. Quartz countertops are engineered from raw materials and resins, though some manufacturers are incorporating recycled materials into their manufacturing process. Granite is also naturally heat resistant, while some quartz contains resins that can release VOCs at high temperatures.
Which is Better – Quartz or Granite?
When choosing between quartz and granite countertops, there are several factors to weigh:
- Quartz is a lower maintenance option requiring no annual sealing and resisting scratches better than granite. It also has more uniform coloring.
- Granite offers a uniquely beautiful natural stone aesthetic with distinctive veining and patterns. No two slabs are exactly the same.
- Quartz costs more on average than granite, but premium granite can be comparable in price to quartz.
- Granite is more heat resistant and eco-friendly as a 100% natural material, but quartz is non-porous.
- Quartz can be damaged by excessive heat from hot pans and trivets should be used. Granite can stain if not sealed properly.
The choice often comes down to priorities. For a low maintenance countertop that retains its like-new appearance, quartz is hard to beat. If you love the striking visual appeal of natural stone and don’t mind extra sealing, granite brings a one-of-a-kind beauty. Consider how each material fits your lifestyle, design tastes, and budget to pick the best option for your space. Consult with knowledgeable countertop providers to view slabs in person.
Frequently Asked Questions About Quartz vs Granite Countertops
Is quartz or granite better for kitchen countertops?
Quartz is often viewed as the better choice for kitchen countertops because it is very stain and scratch resistant, requires no sealing, and stands up well to heavy daily use. Granite can work well in kitchens if properly sealed and maintained.
What are the disadvantages of quartz countertops?
Potential disadvantages of quartz include higher cost on average vs granite, more visible seams, and susceptibility to damage from excessive heat. Quartz also lacks the natural variation and uniqueness of granite.
Can quartz countertops stain?
Quartz is non-porous so it does not easily stain from spills and daily use. However, prolonged exposure to certain materials like wine, oil, and strong chemicals can potentially stain quartz. Overall it resists stains remarkably well with proper care.
Does quartz need to be sealed?
No, quartz does not require any sealing, unlike natural stone countertops such as granite. The resins make quartz non-porous so fluids do not easily penetrate the surface. However, quartz should still be cleaned with mild soap and water regularly.
Is quartz healthier than granite?
Both materials are considered food-safe and non-toxic. Neither will harbor dangerous bacteria with routine cleaning. Some lower quality granite can be mildly radioactive. High quality quartz and granite from reputable suppliers are equally healthy choices.
How often should you seal granite countertops?
Granite countertops should be sealed every 1-2 years using a penetrating sealer. New granite can be sealed right away before use. More frequent sealing may be needed for granite in the kitchen or other high use areas. Check for worn spots annually.
Is quartz cooler than granite?
Quartz does tend to stay cooler to the touch than natural stone like granite or marble. The resins in quartz result in a less heat conductive surface. This makes quartz more comfortable on bare elbows or arms. Granite warms up faster.
Is granite going out of style?
Granite remains highly popular and does not appear to be going out of style anytime soon. Home trends come and go, but natural granite has appealed to homeowners for decades and maintains its prestige. Granite offers a timeless, luxurious look.
Conclusion
When comparing quartz and granite countertops, there are tradeoffs to consider in terms of appearance, durability, maintenance, cost, and eco-friendliness. For many buyers, the low maintenance qualities of quartz make it the top choice to retain its flawless beauty over years of heavy use. Granite brings unmatched natural beauty, heat resistance, and eco-friendly appeal, but requires more upkeep. There is no universally superior material – the right choice depends on your priorities. Consult a professional to view slabs in person and make an informed decision for your home.