When it comes to choosing countertops for your kitchen or bathroom, two popular options are butcher block and quartz. Both offer distinct advantages, but one key consideration for many homeowners is cost. So are butcher block countertops cheaper than quartz?
An Overview of Butcher Block and Quartz Countertops
Butcher block countertops are made from blocks of wood that are glued and pressed together. The wood is usually maple or oak, chosen for its hardness and resistance to moisture and stains. Butcher block needs to be oiled periodically to maintain its luster and water resistance.
Quartz countertops are engineered stone slabs made from quartz crystals blended with resins and color pigments. The resulting material is non-porous, stain resistant, and durable. Quartz requires little maintenance besides regular cleaning.
Comparing the Costs of Butcher Block and Quartz
When comparing costs, there are a few factors to consider:
Material Cost
- Butcher block slabs run $30-90 per square foot on average.
- Quartz slabs range from $70-120 per square foot on average.
So in terms of sheer material cost, butcher block is typically cheaper than quartz.
Installation Cost
Installation fees add on top of material costs. Professional installation tends to run:
- $40-100 per hour for butcher block.
- $50-150 per hour for quartz.
Butcher block is generally simpler to install, since it usually doesn’t require seam work. So installation may cost less than with quartz.
Total Project Cost
For a typical 30 square foot countertop project:
- Butcher block could cost $1500-4000 total.
- Quartz could cost $3000-7000 total.
So when factoring in both material and installation, butcher block generally costs $1000-3000 less than quartz for an average sized project.
Factors That Impact the Costs
There are some variables that can affect the total price tag for both butcher block and quartz:
- Type of wood or stone: Exotic woods and premium quartz blends cost more. Domestic maple and oak or standard quartz colors are most budget friendly.
- Custom fabrication: Custom edges, cutouts, and thickness will increase labor time and expenses. Standard rectilinear shapes are most affordable.
- Discounts and sales: Check for wood and stone sales throughout the year. Bundle countertop installation with other remodeling services for possible discounts.
- DIY vs professional installation: DIY installation saves on labor fees, but has more risk for mistakes.
So while butcher block typically costs less than quartz, the specifics of your project could potentially shift the price points. Get detailed quotes before making a final decision.
Factoring In Other Cost Considerations
Though initial price is important, keep these other cost factors in mind:
- Lifespan: With proper care, both options can last 15-30 years. But quartz may be more resistant to scratches and Water damage over time.
- Maintenance: Butcher block needs periodic oiling and sealing. Quartz just needs cleaning.
- Resale value: Quartz may recoup more value if selling your home. But quality butcher block also appeals to buyers.
So consider long term costs, not just initial pricing. Higher upfront cost may pay off down the road.
Key Takeaways: Butcher Block vs. Quartz Costs
When comparing only upfront expenses, butcher block countertops tend to be $1000-3000 cheaper than quartz for the average kitchen. But if maintenance, durability, and resale value are priorities, quartz may justify its higher price point.
Carefully weigh your budget, design goals, and long term needs. And get multiple quotes before deciding between quartz and wood. With accurate pricing information, you can determine which option makes the most financial sense for your home.