Kitchen and bathroom countertops are an important design element that can significantly impact the look and feel of your home. Two popular countertop materials are solid surface and quartz. While they share some similarities, there are key differences between solid surface vs quartz countertops. Understanding the pros and cons of each can help you choose the best option for your needs and budget.
Introduction
When selecting countertops, you’ll want to consider factors like appearance, durability, maintenance, and cost. Solid surface and quartz both offer attractive, low-maintenance options that resist scratches, heat, and stains. But they achieve these benefits through different means.
Solid surface countertops are made from a blend of acrylic polymers and mineral fillers. The material is customizable, non-porous, and can be repaired if damaged. Quartz countertops contain crushed quartz crystals combined with resins and pigments. This makes them very hard and scratch-resistant.
Below is an in-depth comparison between solid surface vs quartz countertops covering performance, cost, styles, and other considerations.
Appearance
Solid Surface
- Seamless look since material can be fabricated into one continuous surface.
- Matte or slight glossy finish.
- Wide variety of colors, patterns, and textures available. Can be customized.
- Can mimic look of natural stone like marble.
Quartz
- Has a sparkly, stone-like appearance from quartz crystals.
- More limited color options than solid surface. Most have neutral tones with flecks.
- Variety of finishes from matte to polished.
- Visible seams since not fabricated as one piece.
Durability and Longevity
Solid Surface
- Softer than natural stone but resists scratches better than laminate.
- Prone to cuts and scratches from sharp objects. Avoid direct knife contact.
- Heat-resistant to about 350°F. Use trivets for hot pans.
- Stains can be removed since material is non-porous.
- Seamless installation gives an elegant, uniform look.
Quartz
- Extremely hard and scratch-resistant surface.
- Can withstand direct cuts and impacts from knives.
- Heat-resistant to around 450°F. Won’t burn or scorch.
- Resists stains better than solid surface.
- Seams are more visible between slabs.
Maintenance and Cleaning
Solid Surface
- Requires frequent cleaning to keep free of grease and dirt buildup.
- Simple cleaning with mild soap and water. Avoid abrasive cleaners.
- Can be revived by sanding out light scratches. Deep damage needs professional repair.
Quartz
- Very low maintenance. Simple wipedowns keep clean.
- Spills can be cleaned with soap and water.
- Virtually stain proof. Resists most chemicals.
- Scratches and damage are difficult to repair. May need replacement.
Cost Comparison
Solid Surface
- $50-$100 per square foot installed.
- Lesser expensive colors and standard edges reduce cost.
- Long-term cost increased by occasional professional repairs.
Quartz
- $80-$150 per square foot installed.
- More expensive than solid surface on average.
- Very durable so unlikely to need repairs or replacement.
Styles and Edge Profiles
Solid Surface
- Can be fabricated seamlessly into one piece with integrated sink.
- Wide variety of edge profiles like beveled, ogee, and easi-edge.
- Many colors and patterns to match any style.
Quartz
- Limited to slab sizes for countertops with seams between.
- Edge profiles include squared, beveled, bullnose, and ogee.
- More consistent natural or stone-like patterns.
Primary Differences
- Solid surface is more customizable while quartz offers a harder, stone-like finish.
- Quartz is nearly indestructible while solid surface can scratch and stain.
- Solid surface requires more regular cleaning while quartz is virtually maintenance-free.
- Solid surface can be repaired but quartz will likely need replacement if damaged.
- Quartz costs more on average due to its durability and low maintenance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for heavy use in kitchens?
Quartz is the better choice for kitchens that will see heavy use. Its extreme durability and scratch-resistance make it ideal for chopping, cutting, and placing hot items. Solid surface can withstand normal use but requires more care.
Can you repair damaged solid surface countertops?
Yes, minor damage like light scratches and scuffs can be sanded out to restore solid surface countertops. Deeper cuts may need professional repair by patching and resurfacing the damaged section. Anything impacting seams or structural integrity will need replacement.
Do quartz countertops need to be sealed?
No, quartz countertops do not require regular sealing like natural stone. The material is non-porous so sealing is unnecessary. Simply cleaning with soap and water is all that is needed to maintain quartz.
Can you find quartz that looks like marble?
Yes, many quartz varieties are designed to mimic the look of marble. Quartz has veining and patterns that give it a realistic natural stone appearance while still providing extra durability.
Is heat damage covered under warranty?
It depends on the brand. Many warranties cover heat damage only up to a certain temperature, around 450°F. Direct contact with very hot pans can cause localized damage not covered by warranties on quartz or solid surface countertops.
Conclusion
Solid surface and quartz both offer attractive, low-maintenance countertops perfect for busy kitchens and baths. Key differences come down to customization vs. durability, and repair ability vs. stain-resistance. For a classic customized look, solid surface allows more design flexibility. But for rugged durability, quartz is virtually indestructible. Consider how you use your kitchen, your desired aesthetic, and your budget to decide between these two excellent countertop options. Consult with knowledgeable countertop installers as well to match the right material to your home and lifestyle.