Composition of Quartz and Granite
Granite is an igneous rock made of interlocking mineral crystals including quartz, feldspar, and mica. It forms deep within the earth’s crust and emerges as large slabs that are mined and cut into countertops. Granite has a sparkly, elegant appearance from the various mineral deposits.
Quartz countertops contain ground natural quartz crystals combined with polyresin binders. Quartz makes up about 90% of engineered stone slabs, with polymers added for cohesion and consistency. The resins allow quartz to take on varied colors and patterns.
Cost Comparison Between Quartz and Granite
When it comes to price, quartz countertops tend to cost less than granite. Here is a breakdown of typical installed costs per square foot:
- Quartz: $80-140 per square foot installed
- Granite: $60-150 per square foot installed
The cost ranges account for differences in material grades, colors, textures, and regional labor rates. While high-end granite can get very pricey, entry-level quartz costs marginally less.
Factors Affecting Quartz and Granite Costs:
- Quartz: color, pattern, thickness
- Granite: stone type, color, thickness, edge style
So quartz has a slight edge when it comes to overall affordability. But there are other factors to weigh when choosing between them.
Appearance of Quartz vs Granite
In terms of aesthetics, granite has an elegant, timeless look with natural variation. It comes in diverse colors and patterns based on mineral deposits in the stone. Granite provides a unique appearance.
Quartz offers consistent colors and patterns. Engineered quartz lacks natural veining but makes up for it with technology-driven designs. There are myriad options inspired by natural stone as well as bold solid colors and aggregations.
So granite excels in natural beauty, while quartz offers cutting-edge styles. It comes down to your design sensibilities.
Durability Comparison
Quartz is harder and less porous than granite. The resin binders make quartz more flexible and resistant to cracks. Quartz countertops are near indestructible for busy kitchens.
Granite is also durable but can chip or stain if not sealed properly. Annual sealing is recommended to prevent damage. Granite can last a lifetime with proper care.
When it comes to durability, quartz often wins out with virtually no maintenance required. But granite can also perform well with regular sealing.
Maintenance Needs
Quartz needs virtually zero maintenance since it is non-porous. Simple cleaning with soap and water keeps quartz looking pristine. No sealing is required.
Granite is slightly more porous and requires periodic sealing to prevent stains. Annual sealing is ideal. Granite also needs gentle cleaning agents to avoid dulling. More maintenance is involved than with quartz.
The fact that quartz requires less upkeep is a point in its favor for busy households. But granite only needs an annual sealant application to stay protected.
Which is Better for Your Budget?
For shoppers on a tight budget, quartz is generally the more wallet-friendly option. The lower material and installation costs give quartz an affordability advantage. Simple maintenance needs also save money down the road.
However, granite can also fit many budgets, with exotic stones being the priciest. Having to seal granite yearly does add to long-term costs as well. There are affordable granite options, but quartz starts lower.
Focusing on lower-cost granite types and minimizing edge upgrades can offer savings. But quartz still wins for pure value. The newness of the material also contributes to lower costs.
Is the Investment Worth It?
Both granite and quartz provide strong ROI if you ever sell your home. Quartz counters may recoup 80-100% of costs, while granite returns 50-80% on average. So in terms of investment, quartz typically retains its value better.
But granite still offers long-lasting luxury and uniqueness that quartz cannot mimic. For many buyers, the splurge is worth it. But those wanting maximum value return may lean toward quartz for its lower cost and easier maintenance.
Either material adds value and appeal to your home. It comes down to setting a realistic budget and deciding which aesthetic you prefer. If costs are close, go with the look you love.
Key Takeaways on Quartz vs. Granite Costs
- Quartz is generally 10-15% cheaper than granite installed
- Lower-end quartz costs less than basic granite options
- High-end exotic granite is the most expensive option
- Quartz requires essentially no maintenance
- Granite needs annual sealing to prevent staining
- Quartz offers technology-driven colors and patterns
- Granite provides natural beauty and veining
- For sheer affordability, quartz wins out over granite
- But granite can work on tight budgets by limiting upgrades
FAQs About Quartz vs Granite Costs
Is quartz actually cheaper than granite?
Yes, on average quartz countertops cost 10-15% less than granite installed. Quartz starts lower than granite, with mid to high-end granite being the priciest option.
Does quartz or granite increase home value more?
Both countertop materials boost home value significantly. But quartz often recoups a higher percentage of its cost at resale – between 80-100% compared to 50-80% for granite. So for return on investment, quartz has a slight edge.
Why is quartz less expensive than granite?
There are a few reasons quartz costs less than natural granite:
- Quartz is engineered, so less raw stone material is used
- Technology makes quartz fabrication more efficient
- More granite suppliers leads to higher stone costs
- Quartz patterns involve less human craftsmanship
Does quartz staining over time drive costs up?
Quartz does not stain easily thanks to its non-porous surface, so staining is not a cost factor. Quartz requires very little maintenance overall, one of its big pluses.
Is white quartz cheaper than colored quartz?
On average, white and lighter quartz colors cost less than darker, bolder hues. Patterns and special finishes also increase the quartz price per square foot. But even high-end quartz costs less than many types of granite.
Is it worth paying more for granite?
Granite is a premium natural stone with timeless beauty, so for many buyers it is worth the higher cost. Being able to have an elegant, unique kitchen or bath can make granite worth the splurge.
The Bottom Line
While high-end granite has prestige, quartz delivers the most affordability and value per square foot. For cost-conscious consumers, quartz is the smarter budget choice. But premium granite counters still hold classic, luxurious appeal worth the investment for many homeowners.
The key is to focus on the factors behind pricing for each material: composition, durability, maintenance, and appearance. Weigh your budget, kitchen needs, and design goals carefully. Visit showrooms to see quartz and granite options in person. Set a realistic budget and find a quality fabricator to install your new countertops.
With either granite or quartz, you can enjoy beautiful, long-lasting countertops that boost functionality and home value. Let your practical needs and design vision guide you to the best choice for your unique space and lifestyle.