Granite and quartz are two of the most popular materials for kitchen and bathroom countertops. They are both natural stones that are durable, stylish, and add value to a home. However, they differ in appearance, maintenance, and cost. So which one is more expensive – granite or quartz?
An Overview of Granite Countertops
Granite is an igneous rock that is mined from quarries around the world. It is an extremely hard and durable natural stone that can last for decades with proper care. Granite’s signature characteristic is its natural variations in color, veining, and pattern – no two granite slabs are exactly alike.
Pros of Granite:
- Extremely durable and scratch-resistant
- Available in hundreds of unique colors and patterns
- Can be polished to a glossy or honed matte finish
- Adds high-end luxury appeal to kitchens and baths
- Retains its value well; increases home resale value
Cons of Granite:
- More porous than quartz; requires yearly resealing
- Can stain from spills if not sealed properly
- Needs to be handled with care to avoid cracks and chips
- Higher installation costs than quartz
Granite countertops range in price from $50 – $120 per square foot installed. The exact cost depends on the granite color, edge treatments, and local labor costs. More exotic granite varieties can cost over $200 per square foot.
An Overview of Quartz Countertops
Quartz countertops are engineered stone made from crushed quartz crystals combined with resins and pigments. The result is a man-made material that mimics the look of natural stone but has increased consistency and durability.
Pros of Quartz:
- Extremely low maintenance; doesn’t need annual sealing
- Resistant to stains, scratches, cracks, and heat
- Consistent color and pattern; no natural variation
- Easy to clean and keep looking new
- Cheaper installation cost than granite
Cons of Quartz:
- Limited color and style options compared to granite
- Made from engineered materials, not 100% natural stone
- Can develop a hazy film over time that requires buffing
- Doesn’t have the prestigious high-end appeal of granite
Quartz countertops typically range from $70 – $120 per square foot installed. The cost depends on the brand, color/pattern, and edge treatments. On average, quartz is 10-20% less expensive than natural granite.
Is Granite or Quartz More Expensive?
When it comes to upfront costs, quartz countertops are generally less expensive than granite. The main reasons are:
- Quartz has lower material costs – It is an engineered product made from crushed natural stone and resins, so the raw materials are cheaper than mining and cutting whole granite slabs.
- Quartz has lower installation costs – It doesn’t require as much custom cutting and fitting as natural stone. The installation process is simpler than granite.
- More affordable quartz options – The lowest-priced quartz options start around $40/square foot. Affordable granite is rare below $70/square foot.
However, granite may be a better value in the long run for a few reasons:
- Higher resale value – Granite is more prestigious and can better retain its value. This leads to higher home resale value.
- More durable – Granite is less prone to damage from heat or chipping. It can last a lifetime if cared for.
- Easier to repair – Small scratches in granite can be buffed out, while damage in quartz usually requires replacing the entire slab.
- More unique – With nearly unlimited variety, granite offers rarer options that increase in value over time.
The Importance of Professional Installation
Proper installation is crucial with either granite or quartz countertops. Hiring an experienced fabricator will help ensure:
- A precise custom fit for your counters and backsplash
- Correct anchoring to the cabinet base for support
- A beautifully polished finish and professional seams
- Proper sealing to prevent stains and cracks
Trying to save money with DIY countertop installation often leads to cracks, uneven seams, and other flaws down the road. Invest in a quality fabricator for a long-lasting result.
Factors That Affect the Final Price
Other than the base material costs, several other factors impact the total installed price:
- Edge styles – Decorative ogee, bevel, or bullnose edges add cost over standard eased/pencil edge.
- Thickness – 3 cm slabs run cheaper than 2 cm options with more durability.
- Cutouts – The more sink and cooktop cutouts needed, the higher the installation fees.
- Matching backsplashes – Adding granite or quartz backsplash tiles adds expense but gives a seamless finished look.
- Local labor rates – Countertop installation costs more in areas with higher wages for fabricators.
Is Granite or Quartz Better?
There is no definitively “better” option between granite and quartz. The right choice comes down to your priorities:
Granite is better if you want:
- A classic, high-end look with prestige
- Limitless customization with rare stone varieties
- Maximum durability for generations
- Natural stone aesthetics and appeal
Quartz is better if you want:
- A lower maintenance, stain-resistant surface
- More affordability while maintaining quality
- Consistent color and styling
- Modern vibes over a traditional look
Consulting an expert fabricator can help you pick the best material for your goals, lifestyle, and budget. Be sure to see slabs in person before finalizing your decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is granite or quartz more expensive initially?
Quartz is generally 10-20% cheaper upfront than granite for both material and installation costs.
Which material needs more maintenance?
Quartz is nearly maintenance-free, while granite requires yearly sealing. Granite can stain if not properly sealed.
Which material holds up better over time?
Granite is more resistant to chips, cracks, and heat damage. However, both materials can last decades if properly cared for.
Which material has more style and color options?
Granite comes in a vast array of natural patterns, veins, and colors. Quartz has a much more limited selection that mimics stone.
Is it better to get 3cm or 2cm thick countertop slabs?
3cm slabs are recommended for added durability, especially for kitchen counters. The extra cost is usually worthwhile.
Conclusion
While quartz offers more affordability upfront, granite provides a prestigious high-end look and excellent longevity. For homeowners who can afford granite’s higher initial investment, it often proves to be a wise long-term choice that adds value. However, quartz is ideal for those prioritizing convenience. Consult a professional to weigh the pros and cons of each material for your home. With proper installation and care, both natural granite and engineered quartz can serve as beautiful, functional countertops that will last for decades.