Kitchen countertops are one of the most important elements in any kitchen design. They need to be durable, easy to clean, and aesthetically pleasing. The two most popular options for kitchen countertops are granite and quartz. But which one is the better choice? Here is an in-depth comparison of granite and quartz countertops to help you decide which is better for your kitchen.
Durability
When it comes to durability, both granite and quartz are excellent options that will last for many years in the kitchen.
Granite
Granite is incredibly hard and scratch resistant. It’s formed naturally deep within the earth under extreme heat and pressure. This process makes it an extremely strong and durable stone. Granite countertops can withstand years of daily use without showing significant signs of wear. One of the only things that can damage granite is extreme impact or weight. As long as it is properly installed, a granite countertop can last a lifetime.
Quartz
Quartz countertops are made from ground natural quartz crystals combined with resins and polymers. This engineered composition makes quartz harder and less porous than natural stone. Quartz countertops resist scratches, stains, impact, heat, and chemicals. While not invincible, quartz is highly durable and ideal for busy kitchens. With proper care, a quartz countertop can look like new for over a decade.
Both granite and quartz offer excellent durability for the heart of the kitchen. Granite is naturally strong, while quartz is enhanced by its engineered composition. Both will stand up well to heavy daily use.
Appearance
Granite and quartz both come in a wide variety of colors and patterns to suit any kitchen design aesthetic.
Granite
As a natural stone, no two granite slabs are exactly alike. Granite forms striking, unique patterns and movement within the stone. Granite can be found in varied hues of white, gray, pink, red, brown, and black. The natural patterning gives each granite countertop a one-of-a-kind look. The only downside is that natural stone can be susceptible to scratches, chips, and cracks over time.
Quartz
Quartz allows for much more consistency and uniformity in color and pattern. It comes in a wide selection of colors and visual textures to replicate granite, marble, and other natural stone. Engineered quartz gives homeowners more control over the final look. However, quartz lacks the true uniqueness of natural stone. The pattern tends to look more uniform throughout the slab. Still, the consistency of quartz can be an advantage for some homeowners.
For visual appeal, natural granite provides an unmatched beauty. But for more predictable, consistent aesthetics, quartz is an excellent choice.
Maintenance
Proper maintenance is essential to preserve the beauty and functionality of any countertop material. Granite and quartz have slightly different care requirements.
Granite
Granite requires periodic sealing to prevent stains and damage from liquids. It should be sealed upon installation and then every 1 to 2 years. Always clean granite with gentle PH-neutral cleaners free of harsh chemicals. Granite is susceptible to acids like lemon juice or wine that can etch the surface. Take care to wipe up spills quickly. Overall, with regular sealing and careful cleaning, granite is easy to maintain.
Quartz
One major perk of engineered quartz is that it never needs to be sealed. The resins make quartz non-porous so liquids cannot penetrate the surface. Quartz only needs occasional cleaning with a soft cloth and mild soap and water. You do not have to worry about etching or staining. This makes quartz a very low maintenance option.
For homeowners who want a countertop that requires minimal upkeep, quartz is the more hassle-free choice. Granite needs more careful cleaning and periodic sealing to stay in top condition.
Cost
Granite and quartz are both premium countertop materials that come at a higher cost than options like laminate. Here is how they compare on price:
Granite
Natural granite is generally cheaper than quartz on average. Exact pricing can range from $40 to over $100 per square foot installed. More exotic granite types will be on the higher end. The final cost depends on the stone’s rarity, color, and veining patterns.
Quartz
Quartz countertops run between $80-150 per square foot installed. It is more expensive than most granite but lower than premium priced granite and marble. The exact price depends on the brand, color, and style chosen.
While granite can be a more budget-friendly option for natural stone, quartz offers reliable quality and appearance at a moderate price point. The cost difference between the two is lowering as quartz becomes more widely available.
Is Granite or Quartz Better for Kitchen Countertops?
So is granite or quartz the better choice for your kitchen? Here are some key points to help you decide:
- Granite offers unmatched natural beauty with distinctive patterns and colors. No two slabs are alike.
- Quartz provides striking visuals in a more uniform, controlled palette of colors and textures.
- Both materials are exceptionally durable, but quartz is harder and less prone to damage from impact or scratches.
- Granite needs periodic sealing and more careful cleaning due to its porous nature. Quartz requires minimal maintenance.
- Granite costs less on average than quartz. But premium exotic granite can be more expensive than some quartz options.
In the end, it comes down to your aesthetic preferences and lifestyle needs. For those who love the unique beauty of natural stone, granite is the clear choice. If low maintenance and high durability are top concerns, quartz has the advantage. Both offer gorgeous, functional countertops that can make the kitchen shine for years to come. Consult with a kitchen designer to determine whether granite or quartz is better for your personal style and daily use.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is granite or quartz more durable?
Quartz is harder and more resistant to scratches, chips, cracks, and damage from impact. Granite is still highly durable as natural stone, but quartz’s engineered composition makes it a bit tougher.
Does quartz need sealing like granite?
No. Because quartz is non-porous, it never requires sealing. Granite must be sealed periodically to prevent staining and damage from liquids.
Is heat damage a concern for granite or quartz countertops?
Both materials are generally resistant to heat. But extreme direct heat from hot pans can damage the surface over time. Always use trivets or hot pads. Quartz is slightly more heat resistant.
Which material is easier to clean and maintain?
Quartz only needs occasional cleaning with soap and water. Granite requires careful cleaning with stone-safe cleaners and periodic resealing. For ease of maintenance, quartz is the better choice.
Is granite or quartz more expensive?
On average, installed quartz costs $80-150 per square foot while granite ranges from $40 to over $100 per square foot installed. More exotic, rare granites can be more expensive than some quartz.
Does quartz stain as easily as granite?
No. Because quartz is non-porous it resists stains much better than natural stone. Granite can become stained if spills are left to set. Quartz virtually eliminates staining concerns.
Can you find unique patterns and colors in quartz?
Yes, quartz mimics natural stone patterns and comes in a diverse range of colors. However, quartz lacks the true one-of-a-kind variation that makes each granite slab unique.
Does quartz feel artificial compared to natural granite?
Not at all. Modern quartz closely replicates the look and feel of natural stone. Most people cannot visually tell the difference. Quartz provides a realistic stone-like aesthetic.
Conclusion
When choosing a countertop, granite and quartz both make excellent options that combine beauty and durability. For a natural stone look with unique patterning, granite is unrivaled. If low maintenance and high resistance to damage are priorities, quartz is probably the better choice. Consider how the material fits your kitchen’s style, your daily habits, and your budget. With their comparable virtues, either granite or quartz can make a kitchen countertop shine for a lifetime. Consult a knowledgeable kitchen designer to determine if granite or quartz is the right fit for your home.